No images? Click here

 

Nuclear Weapons Update

There’s an uncomfortable tension between the need to publish things on an ongoing basis—for funding, for attention, to get peers aware of it—and the need to ensure that you have done your due diligence, and have checked and verified everything to the fullest extent... And there is usually a very unhappy settlement between the two.

That uncomfortable tension is part of the day-to-day work of many open source analysts. To manage that tension, analysts focus intently on getting the analysis right. But part of that due diligence—similarly important, but less talked about—is doing right with the analysis.

Geospatial and open source analysts face difficult decisions in their work that have the potential to cause harm. For analysts working on nonproliferation and international security, the implications of those choices can be even more far-reaching. Yet the existence of ethical guidance that can improve this kind of decision making is limited. Perspectives like the one above—paraphrased from a real interview with an analyst—are not uncommon in the field.

Last year, the Stanley Center partnered with Aida al-Kaisy of the Ethical Journalism Network to interview nearly 30 analysts and journalists who work with geospatial data. This summer, we will publish a summary of key findings from those interviews, alongside a collection of case studies developed by Melissa Hanham that model real ethical dilemmas faced by analysts working on these topics. 

We hope that these upcoming publications will support open source analysts at all levels as they navigate the ethical challenges that arise in their work. 

Below, please find more highlights from the center and noteworthy publications by some of our partners and colleagues in the nuclear policy community.

 
 

Highlights

Nuclear Weapons Strategy Consultation. Every few years, the Stanley Center assesses its strategic approaches to programming areas, scopes future opportunities, and makes adjustments to strategic direction with the goal of increasing impact. This summer, the center is convening a diverse group of experts and stakeholders from around the world to consider challenges, gaps, and opportunities in nuclear policy. The goal of these conversations is to help elevate effective approaches and strategies for driving policy progress and collective action globally.

Assessing Ethical Challenges in Geospatial Analysis. To better understand the ethical dilemmas faced by open source analysts in their work, the Stanley Center partnered with the Ethical Journalism Network to interview geospatial analysts and journalism professionals working on issues related to nuclear nonproliferation and international security. An upcoming summary will share key findings from the interviews with a detailed report published later this summer.

Case Studies in Geospatial Analysis Ethics. In the growing community of nuclear weapons policy professionals now using geospatial analysis for their work, there is a need for training tools that help develop ethical decision making. The center will publish a series of practical case studies on geospatial analysis ethics developed by Melissa Hanham that can help train practitioners in making ethically-informed decisions, detecting unethical behavior, and providing a support system in challenging circumstances.

Strategy for Peace Conference. As part of the 61st Strategy for Peace Conference, the center will explore the history and enduring effects of systemic racism in the nuclear weapons policy field. To spark the discussion, a new working paper by Wardah Amir and Sylvia Mishra of the organization Women of Color Advancing Peace, Security, and Conflict Transformation (WCAPS) will analyze how ingrained exclusiveness has stunted progress in nuclear policy for decades.

 
 
 

New & Noteworthy

Spies Like Us. Amy Zegart calls attention to the “thin line separating wise crowds from dangerous mobs” in “The Promise and Peril of Crowdsourced Intelligence,” a recent review for Foreign Affairs. Zegart makes mention of the center’s work on ethical challenges in geospatial analysis.

Arms Control in Today’s (Dis)information Environment. In a three-part series published by Inkstick, National Defense University’s Sarah Jacobs Gamberini, Justin Anderson, and Jaclyn Kerr explore trust in the age of disinformation, its implications for the future of arms control treaties and agreements, and how to enable it.

Weapons of Mass Distortion. A new report by Marina Favaro seeks to identify the emerging technologies most likely to escalate in a crisis, ways to better understand their impacts, and risk reduction measures that could mitigate (and capitalize on the benefits and opportunities) they present.

A Nuclear Risk Reduction Package. The Stockholm Initiative—non-nuclear-weapon states looking to strengthen disarmament diplomacy within the context of the Non-Proliferation Treaty—recently put forward a working paper on nuclear risk reduction ahead of the NPT Review Conference.

Strengthening Safeguards and Export Controls. A recommendation paper from the Vienna Center for Disarmament and Non‑Proliferation captures key takeaways from a workshop series exploring what can be done to mitigate risks posed by emerging technologies.

This Is Not a Drill. False Alarm, a new film by director Nick Lyell, explores the 38 minutes between the imminent nuclear missile warning and its retraction on a January 2018 morning in the Hawaiian Islands. Woven into the hour-long documentary are perspectives of Indigenous peoples in Hawaii who have lived with militarism and colonialism on the islands for generations.

Deep Fake Geography? When Geospatial Data Encounter Artificial Intelligence. A new paper by Bo Zhao on geospatial deep fakes and data literacy helps underscore the need for ethical considerations in #GEOINT.

 
 

For even more updates on our nuclear policy work, follow us on Twitter @StanleyConnect.

Luisa Kenausis
Program Associate, Nuclear Weapons
Stanley Center for Peace and Security

 
 
 
More From the Team

The Stanley Center for Peace and Security partners with people, organizations, and the greater global community to drive policy progress in three issue areas—mitigating climate change, avoiding the use of nuclear weapons, and preventing mass violence and atrocities. The center was created in 1956 and maintains its independence while developing forums for diverse perspectives and ideas. To learn more about our recent publications and upcoming events, please visit stanleycenter.org.

 
FacebookTwitterLinkedIn
 
Stanley Center for Peace and Security
209 Iowa Avenue
Muscatine, Iowa 52761 USA
+1 563 264 1500
www.stanleycenter.org

This message has been sent by the Stanley Center for Peace and Security as a courtesy to past participants of events and others who have expressed interest in our work.

Unsubscribe