|
Antics that occur annually at the Cannes Lions International Festival of Creativity can sometimes feel stranger than fiction. Now they’ve been immortalized in novel form by Paul Catmur, the retired co-founder of New Zealand ad agency Barnes, Catmur & Friends.
I spoke to Paul via email about writing “The Gutter Bar,” a satire of the ad agency set during the booze-soaked conference. The interview has been condescended and edited. Organizers of Cannes Lions did not return requests for comment.
CMO Today: Was there a particular moment from Cannes Lions that inspired the book?
Paul Catmur: It was an accumulation of incidents across multiple award shows. The first red flag was someone casually suggesting, while on a jury, that we swap votes. Another jury member was on track to win a Grand Prix until I pointed out that, as there were no abstentions, he must have voted for his own work. He seemed genuinely baffled that this might be considered a problem.
Possibly the most unsettling moment was a global creative director threatening the job of a newly-appointed creative director if he didn’t start winning awards. Jury shenanigans are bad enough; openly jeopardizing livelihoods is just bullying.
CMO Today: Did writing the book change how you see Madison Avenue?
Catmur: It clarified it. Advertising gave me an extraordinary career. Winning awards was always a sideshow, but getting a late-night call in Cannes asking for someone to come and collect a Gold the next evening was undeniably a thrill. But I also saw how warped the incentives became. The problem wasn’t individual bad actors so much as a system that incentivized winning by any means necessary.
CMO Today: What do you hope people in the industry take away from reading the book?
Catmur: I hope it makes people slightly uncomfortable about how skewed the industry has become. I’ve had great fun in Cannes, and it undoubtedly has a role to play, but it was a huge relief when we started our own agency not to have to worry about creative awards at all. Instead, we focused on being effective at selling stuff. That sentence sounds absurdly obvious, but in many places it wasn’t the priority.
|