Trouble viewing this email?  View in web browser ›

The Wall Street Journal ProThe Wall Street Journal Pro

Pro Sustainable Business Pro Sustainable Business

Sponsored by
Deloitte logo.

The Voluntary Carbon Market Lacks Clarity, Not Money

By Ed Ballard

 

Welcome back. The many events devoted to environmental causes at the World Economic Forum were largely overshadowed by fears of a downturn and a war that is scrambling the global energy map.

But one topic that created some buzz among panelists was the voluntary carbon market, which is expanding fast as more companies fund things like forestry projects to offset their emissions. M. Sanjayan, chief executive officer of Conservation International, said a flood of corporate cash has transformed his field. Three years ago, a big carbon project would invest $5 million in a single site, he said; now it would invest $200 million in five or 10 sites. 

"The barrier isn’t money," he said. "The real barrier right now is clarity." He said governments should set clear rules for the little-regulated market. 

[Continued below]

 
Content from our Sponsor: DELOITTE
Path To Economic Disaster: Climate Inaction Could Cost $178 Trillion By 2070

New research shows the heavy economic toll of unchecked climate change and the $43 trillion opportunity a worldwide net zero transition could net the global economy by 2070.  Read More ›

 

For now, the market continues to evolve rapidly with little oversight. There was enthusiasm on various panels about how technology such as satellite imagery can provide better data about the state of forests, allowing market participants to check that the forests they paid to protect are still standing. There were also warnings about potential unintended consequences from the current explosion of activity.

Speaking about forestry projects in the Amazon, Ricardo Hausmann, director of Harvard University's Growth Lab and a former Venezuelan planning minister, said rewards for tree-planting may backfire. "That's going to create a new incentive to deforest so that you can reforest, and you're going into a cycle," Mr. Hausmann said. The problem boils down to economics: Prices on offer for forest-preservation credits in Latin America, he said, are too low compared with the money that can be made by felling trees to raise cattle. 

This week: Crypto traders; inflation headwinds for carbon trading; 'Who cares if Miami is six meters underwater?'

 ‏‏‎ ‎

Crypto and Carbon

Offset registry seeks to rein in crypto tokens. If you own a carbon credit, you can retire it from circulation to claim responsibility for the climate benefit of the project that generated it—tree-planting, say. But since last year, people have retired millions of credits from the largest credit registry and instead used them as backing for new cryptocurrency tokens. Verra, the nonprofit that runs the registry, now says it will stop allowing this practice, arguing that having an active market for crypto tokens that are based on retired carbon credits creates confusion. The move comes amid broader efforts to improve transparency in the market for carbon credits, which have hard-to-verify climate benefits. 

WeWork founder Adam Neumann
PHOTO: EDUARDO MUNOZ/REUTERS

Verra says it will explore a new way of facilitating carbon credits to be "tokenized" without being retired. Several crypto projects—including one recently launched by WeWork founder Adam Neumann—are seeking to piggyback on the growth of the voluntary carbon market, which is seeing increased demand from companies seeking to offset their emissions. 

 ‏‏‎ ‎

Pricing Emissions

‏‏‎A coal-fired power plant in Hubei province, China, where an emissions-trading system was launched last year. PHOTO: GETTY IMAGES/GETTY IMAGES

Carbon costs more, but inflation puts policy makers in a bind. Nearly a quarter of the world's greenhouse-gas emissions are now covered by a carbon price of some kind, but prices remain too low to rein in global warming and inflation could deter governments from imposing tougher policies that push up energy prices, the World Bank said. 

There are now 36 carbon taxes and 32 emission trading systems in place around the world, the World Bank said, but only 4% of emissions are covered by a carbon price steep enough to spur rapid decarbonization. The report noted some signs that carbon pricing is gaining ground, such as Europe’s carbon border tax—still being thrashed out by lawmakers—and recent progress toward putting a price on shipping emissions at the global shipping regulator.

 

ESG

SEC proposes disclosure rules for funds. Regulators proposed new disclosure and naming requirements for investment funds that tap into worries regarding climate change or social justice, in an effort to address concerns about “greenwashing” by asset managers seeking higher fees. The Securities and Exchange Commission voted to issue two proposals that aim to give investors more information about mutual funds, exchange-traded funds and similar vehicles that take into account environmental, social and governance factors. One of the proposed rules, if adopted, would broaden the SEC’s rules governing fund names, while the other would increase disclosure requirements for funds with an ESG focus.

 

Climate Risk

Don't sweat it, says HSBC responsible investing chief. HSBC Holdings suspended a senior executive who argued that investors didn’t need to worry about climate change and that policy makers were exaggerating the risks, according to people familiar with the matter. The comments from Stuart Kirk, the head of responsible investment and research at HSBC Asset Management, drew criticism from the bank's chief executive and other senior figures who stressed its commitment to climate action. 

“Human beings have been fantastic at adapting to change, adapting to climate emergencies and we will continue to do so. Who cares if Miami is six meters underwater in a hundred years?”

— Stuart Kirk, head of responsible investment and research, HSBC Asset Management

🎁 HSBC's ESG aims. HSBC's mixed messaging undermines its effort to grow in the market for financial products that target environmental, social and governance benefits, said Clare Reilly, chief engagement officer at PensionBee, a U.K. pension provider that owns shares in HSBC through index funds. HSBC has said its asset-management arm “treats climate change risk as a key feature of the investment decision-making process,” and the bank has a target to provide $1 trillion of sustainable finance and investment by 2030. Even if Mr. Kirk's views aren't shared across the bank, "that failure of corporate strategic alignment is worrying," Ms. Reilly said.

—Ed Ballard

 ‏‏‎ ‎

Energy Transition

Ukraine war threatens shift, leaders warn. Europe’s scramble to wean itself off Russian energy will lead to new short-term investments in coal, oil and natural gas, energy and government officials said in Davos. Some also warned that the crisis may also give producers an opening to invest in longer-term fossil fuel projects. “We see a lot of people talking about a lot of things which I would have never guessed would be back on the table,” said Joe Kaeser, chairman of Siemens Energy, “like drilling in the North Sea.”

$13.2 billion

Financing secured by natural-gas exporter Venture Global LNG for a new export facility in Louisiana, the first new U.S. plant to get a green light in three years 

But net-zero pressure persists. TotalEnergies said it would buy a 50% stake in U.S. renewables company Clearway Energy Group in a deal worth about $2.4 billion, expanding its reach in the U.S. green-power sector. The move followed Total's $2.5 billion purchase of a 25% stake in India's solar-energy giant Adani Green Energy last year and its successful bid for offshore-wind rights for a site off the Carolinas in the U.S.

 ‏‏‎ ‎

ESG Insights

BNY Mellon's Investment Management Arm Fined for Misleading ESG Claims 

The ESG credentials of Bank of New York Mellon may get dented as the bank's investment management arm was fined $1.5 million by the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission for alleged misstatements and omissions about its ESG considerations. The SEC said that some of the mutual funds under BNY Mellon Investment Adviser had misleading claims about its ESG criteria and stock-picking process between July 2018 and September 2021. The firm didn't admit or deny the SEC's findings. The fine shows that the SEC aims to hold investment advisers accountable for their ESG claims, said Adam S. Aderton, co-chief of the SEC Enforcement Division's Asset Management Unit and a member of the ESG Task Force. Growth in sustainable funds has accelerated over the past couple of years. In 2021, U.S. sustainable funds recorded net $70 billion in flows for the year, up 35% from 2020, according to data from Morningstar.

This is a sample of exclusive analysis of sustainability news from the Journal’s environment, social and governance (ESG) research analysts, whose work is primarily published by Dow Jones Newswires to help institutional investors and wealth managers integrate ESG factors into portfolio models, risk management programs and financial advice. The commentary by our research analysts is independent of the news coverage by reporters at the Journal. For more information about Dow Jones Newswires, click here.

 ‏‏‎ ‎

Around the Web

"What happened in reality was a very different situation." Three companies discuss their sustainability failures. (Greenbiz)

The European Union's defense agency wants to "measure and benchmark" the defense industry's contribution to sustainability. (Responsible Investor)

A lithium supply crisis could dent the world’s chances of meeting its climate goals. (Bloomberg) 

U.K. banks and insurers that fail to manage climate risks could suffer a 10% to 15% hit to their annual profits, the Bank of England said after conducting its first climate stress tests. (Financial Times) 

Four in 10 of the companies reporting to environmental disclosure group CDP have no information about the origins of the deforestation-linked commodities they buy. (Edie)   

Charm Industrial used plant waste to sequester thousands of tons of carbon. The question is scalability. (MIT Technology Review) 

The global shipping regulator is moving toward a carbon price for shipping emissions. (Climate Home) 

The future of oil production in California could hinge on a court hearing in Bakersfield scheduled for Thursday. (Politico)

How a French bank set the gold standard for climate action. (Quartz) 

Why not put solar panels in space? (Energy Monitor)

 

Deloitte Logo.
 

Contact Us

✍️ Feedback on this newsletter? We would love to hear from you, so please get in touch.
 
Desktop, tablet and mobile. Desktop, tablet and mobile.
Access WSJ‌.com and our mobile apps. Subscribe
Apple app store icon. Google app store icon.
Unsubscribe   |    Newsletters & Alerts   |    Contact Us   |    Privacy Notice   |    Cookie Notice
Dow Jones & Company, Inc. 4300 U.S. Ro‌ute 1 No‌rth Monm‌outh Junc‌tion, N‌J 088‌52
You are currently subscribed as [email address suppressed]. For further assistance, please contact Customer Service at pro‌newsletter@dowjones.com.
Copyright 2022 Dow Jones & Company, Inc.   |   All Rights Reserved.
Unsubscribe