No images? Click here

 

Nuclear Weapons Update

March 2021

Public rhetoric around emerging technologies and nuclear weapons risk might be catching up to expert discussions on the topic. Perhaps in ways that should give pause.

In its Integrated Review, the UK recently announced that it is raising the limit on its nuclear arsenal due, in part, to investments by other states "in novel nuclear technologies and…‘warfighting’ nuclear systems" that "pose a threat to strategic stability."

Attention-grabbing headlines followed. Several outlets emphasized emerging technologies as a driver behind the change in UK nuclear policy.

Discussions on nuclear weapons and emerging technologies used to be lower key. Now they are part of nuclear postures, magnified by news editors, and increasingly woven into public narratives. While the Integrated Review was met with significant critique, this public narrative of the threat of emerging technologies might itself be a cause for concern.

Big headlines suggest that the public policy conversation on emerging technologies and nuclear weapons might too easily play into troubling themes of threats and security dilemmas. Those themes risk crowding out discussions of solutions to mitigate the risks of emerging technologies and avoid the use of nuclear weapons—without increasing their numbers or roles in security strategies.

Our nuclear policy programming at the Stanley Center aims to enhance understanding of those risks and to promote practical solutions. If recent headlines are any indication, then there is an increasing need for urgency in our collective efforts to advance those solutions.

 
 

Highlights

Accelerator Initiative. The Stanley Center created the Accelerator Initiative in 2019 to offer early-career women working in nuclear weapons and international security policy a unique opportunity to develop their careers and widen their professional networks by participating in Stanley Center programming. Due to the ongoing restrictions on travel and the limited networking opportunities offered by virtual events, we have decided to postpone opening applications for the third cohort of the Accelerator Initiative (previously referred to as the 2021 Accelerator Initiative) until global conditions for travel look more promising. Follow us on Twitter for more updates.

Assessing Ethical Challenges in Geospatial Analysis. Open source analysts today face complex decisions in their work that could have far-reaching consequences. To better understand these ethical dilemmas, the Stanley Center partnered with the Ethical Journalism Network to interview geospatial analysts and journalism professionals working on issues related to nuclear nonproliferation and international security. The upcoming report will synthesize these findings and establish a baseline understanding of the current ethical decisionmaking practices in the field.

Case Studies in Geospatial Analysis Ethics. In the growing community of nuclear weapons policy professionals now using geospatial analysis for their work, there is a need for training tools that help develop ethical decisionmaking. The center will publish a series of practical case studies on geospatial analysis ethics developed by Melissa Hanham that can help train practitioners in making ethically-informed decisions, detecting unethical behavior, and providing a support system in challenging circumstances.

Strategy for Peace Conference. The 61st Strategy for Peace conference will explore the history and enduring effects of systemic racism in the nuclear field. To spark the discussion, a new paper by Wardah Amir and Sylvia Mishra of the organization Women of Color Advancing Peace, Security, and Conflict Transformation (WCAPS) will analyze how ingrained exclusiveness has stunted progress in nuclear policy for decades.

Nuclear Weapons Strategy Consultation. Every few years, the Stanley Center assesses its strategic approaches to programming areas, scopes future opportunities, and makes adjustments to strategic direction with the goal of increasing impact. This year, the center will convene a diverse group of external experts and stakeholders from around the world to consider challenges, gaps, and opportunities in nuclear policy, as well as what will effectively drive policy progress and collective action globally.

 
 
 

New & Noteworthy

The Next Fifty Years of Nuclear Proliferation. A collection of essays published by research professor Sharon Squassoni for Nuclear Boundaries Initiative examines a wide range of overlapping issues related to US and international nuclear policy. The final essay, by Ankit Panda, describes how emerging technologies may disincentivize nuclear proliferation in some contexts by limiting the survivability of a nuclear force for new proliferators.

Nuclear Weapons in the UK Integrated Review (IR). The UK government released its Global Britain in a Competitive Age policy paper in mid-March. In BASIC’s analysis of the IR, Sebastian Brixey-Williams analyzes the nuclear weapons dimensions of the Review, including the mention of future emerging technologies as a possible justification for revising UK’s commitment to negative security assurances at a later date.

Emerging Technologies Literature Review. The Center for Global Security Research has published Brad Roberts’s review and assessment of literature about emerging and disruptive technologies and strategic stability with a focus on making it accessible for policymakers. The accompanying annotated bibliography distills the burgeoning scholarship on military aspects of new technical domains into a taxonomic structure that allows for analysis of the complex interaction among multiple technologies.

Countering Racism in Nuclear Policy. How do structures of racism, exclusion, domination, and exploitation affect nuclear weapons and nonproliferation? An annotated bibliography by Princeton University’s Program on Science and Global Security lists resources for exploring these complex interactions and engaging with alternative frameworks of ideas, institutions, and policies on nuclear issues.

Blockchain in Nuclear Disarmament. Does blockchain technology provide a possible solution for overcoming the problem of insufficient trust for cooperative nuclear disarmament? In the conceptual report published by King’s College London, The Trust Machine, Dr. Lyndon Burford reviews existing research on blockchain for nuclear safeguards and describes how the technology can facilitate data verification processes and increase international cooperation in arms control.

Nuclear Hotlines Podcast Interview. Back Story with Dana Lewis interviews Philip Reiner of the Institute for Security and Technology and former British Rear Admiral John Gower about the necessity for a new nuclear hotline for nations with nuclear weapons that can remain operational under extreme conditions to maintain trust and communications in emergencies.

Hotline Between Two Koreas. A special report by Moon Chung-in and Boo Seung-chan for NAPSNet examines the history, status, and future of the hotlines linking South and North Korea. These communications channels comprise an important—though excessively politicized—component of confidence-building measures amid a conflict that has lasted for more than 70 years.

 
 

For even more updates on our nuclear policy work, follow us on Twitter @StanleyConnect.

Ben Loehrke
Program Officer, Nuclear Weapons
Stanley Center for Peace and Security

 
 
 

Not a subscriber yet? Sign up to receive updates from the Stanley Center on upcoming opportunities and important takeaways from our collaborations.

SUBSCRIBE

The Stanley Center for Peace and Security partners with people, organizations, and the greater global community to drive policy progress in three issue areas—mitigating climate change, avoiding the use of nuclear weapons, and preventing mass violence and atrocities. The center was created in 1956 and maintains its independence while developing forums for diverse perspectives and ideas. To learn more about our recent publications and upcoming events, please visit stanleycenter.org.

 
FacebookTwitterLinkedIn
Stanley Center for Peace and Security
209 Iowa Avenue
Muscatine, Iowa 52761 USA
+1 563 264 1500
www.stanleycenter.org
This message has been sent by the Stanley Center for Peace and Security as a courtesy to past participants of events and others who have expressed interest in our work.
Unsubscribe