In our last issue, I asked:
Do you own ESG funds? Why or why not?
Readers expressed intensely different views on these funds that purport to make the world [E]nvironmentally cleaner, [S]ocially fairer and [G]overned better.
Investing is about financial return. Such considerations as environmental and social "good," and much of what passes today as "governance," are vague and indefinable irrelevancies. They might correlate with financial considerations and might not. If an ESG fund makes you feel virtuous, go for it. But don't expect to eat virtue for breakfast or use it to pay rent.
—Graydon DeCamp, Elk Rapids, Mich.
I do have about 5% of my portfolio invested in an ESG fund. The fees are higher for the fund, about triple the cost just like you have mentioned. The higher cost is why I only have a small fraction in an ESG fund. I would invest more, if the fees were comparable to my other investment funds.
—Chris Gillett, Portland, Ore.
Energy Supplies Growth!
—Kenneth Yap, Singapore
Yes, people do care about the future of the environment and other causes, thank goodness. Am I wearing a halo? OK then.
—Kate McCarthy, Westlake, Ohio
If I could cheaply buy an index fund of stocks eschewed by the ESG crowd, I'd be tempted.
—Mark Waldron, Dayton, Ohio
We make financial decisions based on a broad spectrum of factors: book value vs. market value, free cash flow, potential sales growth, etc. But the mission of the company is an important factor as well. And how they conduct themselves in our economy to many is a very important factor in whether an investment is worthwhile.
—Frank Brannon, Atlanta
When I want to create social change I donate to my favorite causes and/or volunteer — that way I can be reasonably certain I'm being effective and not performative.
—Harley Manning, Reading, Mass.
IMHO, it's just another scam/wrinkle to transfer some naive snowflake's cash into their account.
—Marvin Devoe
My own view? Too many ESG funds cost too much. And I don't think most ESG funds do much — if anything — to make the world a better place, as my colleague James Mackintosh showed last year.
But maybe you don't expect your ESG fund to make the world better. Maybe you just don't want to invest in companies you think are making the world worse.
In that case, I don't see anything wrong with buying an ESG fund, as long as you pay close attention to fees, you confirm that it doesn't own companies you disapprove of and you accept that its returns might not be great.
Realistic expectations will help you avoid being greenwashed.
|