Editor's note

For several years, I’ve been aware – both as a journalist and a citizen – that talking about politics often means disagreement. And not arguments about different opinions – arguments about basic facts.

Luckily, there are political scientists who can take that passing observation and look into it more deeply. That’s what scholars David C. Barker of American University and Morgan Marietta of UMass Lowell have done. In their story today, they look at how the public’s reaction to the Mueller report has taken two forms – “Total exoneration!” and “Impeach Trump!” They use that as a prime example of the dueling facts phenomenon: the “tendency for Red and Blue America to perceive reality in starkly different ways.”

This isn’t just a parlor game. Barker and Marietta say it’s is a growing problem for democracy in America: If people can’t agree on facts, how can they ever solve the nation’s problems?

Today we also have great reads on how fluid dynamics explains sudden dips in the stock market, why the IRS probably won’t cough up President Trump’s tax returns and why writers “return again and again to alchemy.”

Naomi Schalit

Senior Editor, Politics + Society

Top story

Can a country move ahead when its citizens all hold dueling facts? Shutterstock

From ‘Total exoneration!’ to ‘Impeach now!’ – the Mueller report and dueling fact perceptions

David C. Barker, American University School of Public Affairs; Morgan Marietta, University of Massachusetts Lowell

How can a community decide the direction it should go, if its members cannot even agree on where they are? Two political scientists say the growing phenomenon of dueling facts threatens democracy.

Economy + Business

Environment + Energy

if you believe in scientists telling the public about their new research, please support us

Ethics + Religion

Science + Technology

Most read on site

Today’s quote

“Incessant mechanical buzzing doesn’t fit with anyone’s idea of a pleasant community. That’s what drones will bring, though.”

 

Drones to deliver incessant buzzing noise, and packages

 

Garth Paine

Arizona State University

Garth Paine
 

Know someone who may be interested in The Conversation's stories? Please forward this to them and ask them sign up for our newsletter at theconversation.com/us/newsletters