Editor's note

TV host Piers Morgan rejoiced on Good Morning Britain last week after reading about a new study which claimed that eating meat is safe. The study, published in a prestigious medical journal, found that eating red and processed meat does not increase your risk of cancer, cardiovascular disease, diabetes or early death. Morgan couldn’t resist having a pop at vegetarians. “Vegetarians, eat your gruel,” he said. “Go ahead and do it. But it no longer gives you health benefits.”

However, not everyone agreed with the study. Richard Hoffman, for one, argues that these sorts of large studies that provide nutritional advice based on the average of very large populations say nothing about individual differences in risk. People who are overweight or obese, for example, have a different risk profile to people who are a healthy weight, so blanket advice on how much meat they can eat would differ. As Hoffman notes, “a one-size-fits-all policy in nutrition makes no more sense than calculating the average shoe size in a population and recommending that everyone wear that size”.

Other academic experts in Australia were similarly dismissive of the study and listed at least four shortcomings.

In other bovine news, raw milk (read: unpasteurised) is making a comeback, at least in some corners. But don’t ditch the pasteurised stuff yet. While the health benefits of raw milk are still uncertain, other risks, such as consuming harmful bacteria, are more clear. And as 35,000 wildfires tear through Indonesia, air pollution levels are having a hazardous effect on health – on children’s health in particular.

Clint Witchalls

Health + Medicine Editor

Top stories

Photology1971/Shutterstock

Red meat study caused a stir – here’s what wasn’t discussed

Richard Hoffman, University of Hertfordshire

Red meat and processed meat seemed to get the all clear in a recent study but not everyone agrees.

Syda Productions/Shutterstock

Raw milk: the benefits are unclear but the dangers are real

James Blaxland, Cardiff Metropolitan University; Vitti Allender, Cardiff Metropolitan University

More people are drinking unpasteurised milk but what does the evidence say?

A mass prayer for rain to combat the haze in Riau province, Indonesia, September 2019. AFRIANTO SILALAHI / EPA

Indonesia’s huge fires and toxic haze will cause health problems for years to come

Maria C. Lo Bue, United Nations University

Research shows previous fires increased child mortality and reduced growth rates.

Politics + Society

Business + Economy

Health + Medicine

Environment + Energy

Science + Technology

Arts + Culture

 
 
 
 
 
 
 

Featured events

Do editors pander to audiences more than they should?

Bonar Hall University of Dundee, Dundee, Dundee City, DD1 4HN, United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland — The Conversation

Polly Curtis on the future of journalism

Bonar Hall University of Dundee, Dundee, Dundee City, DD1 4HN, United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland — The Conversation

Time for Change: A Climate Conversation

Lindsay Stewart lecture Theatre, Craiglockhart Campus, Glenlockhart Road, Edinburgh, Midlothian, EH14 1DJ, United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland — Edinburgh Napier University

Are we all thin enough yet? How the thin ideal conquered the world

East Road, Cambridge, Cambridgeshire, CB11PT, United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland — Anglia Ruskin University

More events
 

Contact us here to have your event listed.

For sponsorship opportunities, email us here