Editor's note
|
Fact-checking is the kind of job you might wish didn’t need to exist. But 2018 provided yet more proof this once-niche, but quickly-growing, form of public interest journalism plays a vital role in keeping our information ecosystem healthy, and holding our nation’s leaders to account.
This year, The Conversation’s expert FactCheck authors and blind reviewers checked claims that went to the heart of key policy debates and social issues – including energy policy, corporate tax cuts, population, the economy and aged care – and central campaign messages for the Tasmanian, South Australian and Victorian state elections.
Of the 17 claims checked in the 10 FactChecks listed below, the majority were found to be incorrect, a significant exaggeration, statements not supported by evidence, or a dangerous mixture of fact and fiction.
With the New South Wales and federal elections almost upon us, we must all play our part in looking past the rhetoric to the facts, and making sure that when Australia votes, it’s not a vote swayed by falsehoods.
Can you tell which of these claims is fact or furphy?
|
Lucinda Beaman
FactCheck Editor
|
|
|
|
Native title - the legal recognition of Indigenous Australian land rights - is determined under domestic law, not international law.
AAP/Tracey Nearmy
Kate Galloway, Bond University
In an article published in the lead up to Australia Day, WA Liberal Party policy committee chairman Sherry Sufi said "native title can only exist if Australia was settled, not invaded". Is that right?
|
Poker machine reform is at the centre of the upcoming Tasmanian state election.
Dan Peled/AAP
Fabrizio Carmignani, Griffith University
The Tasmanian Liberal party is promoting gaming industry estimates that 'around 5,000 jobs' would be at risk if poker machines were removed from pubs and clubs in Tasmania. Are the estimates correct?
|
South Australian Premier Jay Weatherill, SA Liberal leader Steven Marshall and SA Best leader Nick Xenophon at a leaders’ debate hosted by the ABC.
AAP Image/Morgan Sette
Dylan McConnell, University of Melbourne
SA Liberal Party leader Steven Marshall said that state Labor policy had left South Australians with 'the highest energy prices in Australia' and 'the least reliable grid'. Is that right?
|
One Nation leader Pauline Hanson says Australia has ‘run away rates of immigration’.
MICK TSIKAS/AAP
Liz Allen, Australian National University
One Nation leader Pauline Hanson said Australia is "the highest-growing country in the world", with population growth "double than a lot of other countries". Is that right?
|
Shadow minister for finance Jim Chalmers, speaking on Q&A.
ABC/Q&A
Mark Crosby, Monash University
Was shadow minister for finance Jim Chalmers correct when he said that under the current Coalition government, net debt had doubled? We asked the experts.
|
Minister for Finance Mathias Cormann.
AAP Image/Mick Tsikas
Fabrizio Carmignani, Griffith University
Minister for Finance Mathias Cormann said corporate tax cuts in the US had led to 'stronger investment, stronger growth, a lower unemployment rate and higher wages'. Let's take a closer look.
|
Prime Minister Scott Morrison defended the Coalition’s spending on aged care services after announcing a Royal Commission into the sector.
AAP Image/Mick Tsikas
Peter Whiteford, Crawford School of Public Policy, Australian National University
Prime Minister Scott Morrison has defended the Coalition’s spending on aged care as preparations for a Royal Commission into the sector get underway. We asked the experts to crunch the numbers.
|
Trade Minister Simon Birmingham has said Labor MPs disproportionately come from unions.
ABC
Ray Markey, Macquarie University
Trade Minister Simon Birmingham said "you can’t reflect society if 90% of your members of parliament were chosen from trade unions and worked in trade unions". Let's take a look at the numbers.
|
At the Victorian Liberal Party election campaign launch, Opposition leader Matthew Guy said Labor had presided over a law and order crisis.
AAP Image/James Ross
Don Weatherburn, UNSW
Victorian Opposition leader Matthew Guy said under Premier Daniel Andrews, 'Victoria has won the unenviable title as the state with the country’s highest rate of crime'. Is that right?
|
Queensland Minister for Housing and Public Works Mick de Brenni announced a $2b housing scheme he said would create more affordable housing in the state.
AAP/AARON BUNCH
Stephen Whelan, University of Sydney
Queensland Minister for Housing and Public Works Mick de Brenni made the claim while announcing a $2 billion housing investment scheme. But is the claim correct?
|
|
Featured jobs
|
|
|
|
Monash University — Caulfield, Victoria
|
|
RMIT University — Melbourne, Victoria
|
|
University of Melbourne — Melbourne, Victoria
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|