When does a state cease to be a state? Traditionally, international law recognizes a nation state as having a population, land, a functioning government and the capacity to engage in international relations.

But what does this mean for the status of small nation islands at risk of losing their territory and population due to climate change? This is a very real question for nations such as Tuvalu, which has already taken steps to preserve its statehood in the event that rising sea levels and extreme weather events mean that the physical territory it sits on needs to be abandoned. It has secured an agreement with Australia to ensure it will continue to be seen as a state and is digitizing the country, moving government online and creating a virtual archive of its territory and culture.

“The aim is for Tuvalu to continue existing as a state even when climate change has forced its population into exile and rising seas have done away with its land. It says it will be the world’s first digital nation,” write Avidan Kent and Zana Syla.

Tuvalu isn’t alone, Kiribati, the Maldives and Marshall Islands, among others, are also looking at the issue – as is the International Court of Justice, which recently noted that “once a state is established, the disappearance of one of its constituent elements would not necessarily entail the loss of its statehood.”

But does that ensure statehood for low-lying coastal nations no matter what? Kent and Syla suggest that a closer reading of the ICJ statement “suggests that the court stopped short of explicitly confirming that the flexibility of the term ‘statehood’ could be stretched so far as to mean a state could exist even if completely submerged under the seas.”

Elsewhere this week, we have been explaining how the Trump administration is changing U.S. capitalism and looking at the legality of Israel’s “double tap” attacks.

Matt Williams

Senior International Editor, New York

Some small island states, such as Tuvalu, are at risk of losing their land to rising seas. Romaine W / Shutterstock

What will happen to the legal status of ‘sinking’ nations when their land is gone?

Avidan Kent, University of East Anglia; Zana Syla, University of East Anglia

Sinking island states face an uncertain legal future.

A line of heavily fortified cities in the western Donetsk region stands between Russia’s army and a clear run into central Ukraine. hernandez jose maria/Alamy Live News

Forcing Zelensky to hand Putin Ukraine’s ‘fortress belt’ in Donetsk will lose it the war

Rod Thornton, King's College London; Marina Miron, King's College London

And ‘land swap’ involving Ukraine ceding its strategically vital fortified cities in western Donetsk would be a disaster for Kyiv.

Palestinians mourn the death of five journalists in the Nasser Hotel strike. More than 200 media workers have been killed in Gaza since the beginning of the war in October 2023. Rizek Abdeljawad/Xinhua/Alamy Live News

Was the ‘double tap’ attack on Gaza’s Nasser hospital a war crime? Here’s what the laws of war say

James Sweeney, Lancaster University

The laws of war would prohibit a deliberate double tap strike against a hospital.

The Mercator map exaggerates the area of North America and Eurasia while under-representing the size of much of South America and Africa. NASA's Earth Observatory "Blue Marble" series / Wikimedia Commons

World maps get Africa’s size wrong: cartographers explain why fixing it matters

Jack Swab, University of Tennessee; Derek H. Alderman, University of Tennessee

Maps help shape how we make sense of the world.