Editor's note

Filmmaker Michael Moore doesn’t mind putting a few noses out of joint. And so it is with his latest film Planet of the Humans, which has turned him from a darling of the left to its public enemy #1.

The documentary, on which Moore was executive producer, was released on YouTube and at the time of writing had been watched more than 6.5 million times. It purports to say what “no one else will” – that technologies such as renewable energy are nowhere near as clean as they claim to be.

The response from environmentalists and clean energy advocates has been fast and furious. And predictably, climate deniers are championing the film. So where does the truth lie? Griffith University emeritus professor Ian Lowe today draws on his 50 years of experience studying the energy sector to answer that question.

His balanced, nuanced take reveals the film’s many blunders. But he says the film’s overall message – that infinite growth on a finite planet is “suicide” – is irrefutable.

Lowe’s piece is a good example of why The Conversation exists – to draw on deep expertise to sort facts from the hyperbole. But we cannot continue without your support. This week we launched our annual reader donation campaign, inviting those who like what we do to give. Your tax-deductible donation will help raise the voices of experts above the misinformation that thwarts progess at a time when change is so badly needed.

Nicole Hasham

Section Editor: Energy + Environment

Top stories

planetofthehumans.com

3 times Michael Moore’s film Planet of the Humans gets the facts wrong (and 3 times it gets them right)

Ian Lowe, Griffith University

Environmentalists say the new film has caused untold damage at a time when change has never been more urgent. So why is it so controversial?

Shutterstock

Does nicotine protect us against coronavirus?

Adrian Bauman, University of Sydney; Leah Shepherd, University of Sydney; Melody Ding, University of Sydney

A study from France concluded smoking might protect against coronavirus. But particularly now, in the midst of a pandemic, it's critical we don't take headlines at face value.

David Mariuz/AAP

COVID crisis has produced many negatives but some positives too, including confidence in governments: ANU study

Michelle Grattan, University of Canberra

An ANU study providing a longitudinal examination of the effects of the coronavirus shows a rise in trust in government, and a fall in perceived job security.

Science + Technology

Environment + Energy

Arts + Culture

Cities

Politics + Society

Health + Medicine

Business + Economy

 

Featured jobs

Research Scientist - Plant Biology

— Canberra ACT, Australia

More Jobs
 
 
 
 
 
 

Featured Events & Courses

Evaluation Course Online: Getting Started

Level 21, 15 Broadway, Ultimo, New South Wales, 2007, Australia — University of Technology Sydney

Managing regulation, enforcement and compliance

Brisbane (Venue TBC), Brisbane, Queensland, 4000, Australia — Australia New Zealand School of Government

COVID Conversations

Online webinar, Perth, Western Australia, 6027, Australia — Edith Cowan University

COVID Conversations

Online webinar, Perth, Western Australia, 6027, Australia — Edith Cowan University

More events & courses
 

​Contact us here to list your job, or here to list your event or course.

For sponsorship opportunities, email us here