If Google searches and social media posts are any indicators, lots of people are asking which COVID vaccine is best. But vaccines aren’t like laptops or washing machines, which you can compare online. It’s really hard to compare vaccines, say Wen Shi Lee and Hyon Xhi Tan from the Doherty Institute, because there are many factors on which to compare them and different ways to judge how well they work.

And even if we did come up with a definition of “best”, most of us can’t choose between brands anyway. While vaccine supplies are short, we’re left with whichever vaccine we’re offered right now, all of which have been shown to significantly reduce the harms of COVID. They say waiting for a particular brand can not only be dangerous for us and the people around us, it helps prolong the pandemic.

Meanwhile, it’s no secret the federal government’s COVID vaccination advertisements so far have been criticised for being less than engaging. As it prepares to launch a new ad campaign next month – this one aimed at under 40s – we asked a vaccine communications expert to explain what would actually make for a strong ad campaign.

According to Jessica Kaufman, there are two “dos” and one “don’t”. We need diverse spokespeople, and ads that are a bit entertaining. And we should avoid scare tactics, as research suggests fear-based messaging can actually backfire. Kaufman also sets out some strategies we need to be thinking about alongside an ad campaign to boost vaccination, including behavioural “nudges”, community engagement, and improving access to COVID vaccines.

If you value The Conversation’s fact-based news, direct from the experts, please give a tax-deductible donation today.

Anna Evangeli

Deputy Editor: Health+Medicine

from www.shutterstock.com

Which COVID vaccine is best? Here’s why that’s really hard to answer

Wen Shi Lee, The Peter Doherty Institute for Infection and Immunity; Hyon Xhi Tan, The Peter Doherty Institute for Infection and Immunity

Even if we came up with a definition of what makes the "best" vaccine, we don't have the luxury of choice when vaccines are in short supply.

Shutterstock

Diverse spokespeople and humour: how the government’s next ad campaign could boost COVID vaccine uptake

Jessica Kaufman, Murdoch Children's Research Institute

The federal government is due to launch a new advertising campaign for COVID-19 vaccines in July. This is a chance to offer something more engaging than what we've seen to date.

Luke MacGregor/AAP

There’s a lot we don’t know about the UK trade agreement we are about to sign

Patricia Ranald, University of Sydney

Australia won't release the text until after it is signed.

Richard Wainwright/AAP Image

Police debacle leaves the McGowan government battling to rebuild public trust in the SafeWA app

Tama Leaver, Curtin University

Revelations that WA police accessed data from the state's QR code contact-tracing app threaten to put a serious dent in the public's trust. And this trust is a crucial element of our COVID defences.

Erik Anderson/AAP

Resettling refugees in other countries is not working, nor is it fair. So, why is Australia doing it?

Claire Higgins, UNSW

The home affairs minister says Australia is exploring resettlement overseas for 'broad cohorts' of people. But such deals do not get Australia off the hook.

Darren Carney

Spiders are cloaking Gippsland with stunning webs after the floods. An expert explains why

Lizzy Lowe, Macquarie University

What's going on here? Why do spiders do this after floods and does it happen everywhere?

(YouTube: Friendlyjordies)

Friendlyjordies producer arrest: what is the NSW Police Fixated Persons Investigations Unit and when is it used?

Keiran Hardy, Griffith University

The case may set a precedent about what is fixated behaviour and an appropriate use of the FPIU.

Education

Science + Technology

Environment + Energy

Arts + Culture

Politics + Society

 

Featured jobs

More Jobs
 
 
 
 
 
 

Featured Events & Courses

Why Do Tigers Have Whiskers? A Curious Kids event in Sydney

49 Glebe Point Road, Glebe, New South Wales, 2037, Australia — The Conversation

Curious Kids - The Conversation

191 Boundary St, West End, Queensland, 4101, Australia — The Conversation

The Conversation – Plants and people: the art of living together

Free online event, Queensland, Australia — The Conversation

Blue is the New Green

online webinar, Perth, Western Australia, 6009, Australia — The University of Western Australia

More events & courses
 

​Contact us here to list your job, or here to list your event or course.

For sponsorship opportunities, email us here