What does it mean to lose a tree?

This week, millions of people around the world found out, after someone cut down the Sycamore Gap tree, one of the most famous trees in the United Kingdom. It felt surprisingly bad.

Why would we mourn one tree out of the billions in the world? For Rebecca Banham, a Tasmanian sociologist, the answer is clear. We mourn iconic trees because it feels as if they have always been there – a stable presence. Famous trees contribute to our sense of “ontological security” – our trust that our world is stable and predictable. When they die – or worse, are felled – it feels a little like a missing tooth in your mouth. You can feel its absence.

Many Australians still remember the outrage at hearing of the death of El Grande, a giant mountain ash accidentally burned by foresters in Tasmania. Others might remember the unsolved poisoning of Queensland’s Tree of Knowledge, under whose limbs shearers organised for better conditions.

In her research, Banham interviewed Tasmanians who draw meaning from the state’s famous forests. As one of her interviewees, Leon, told her: “These places should be left alone, because in 10,000 years they could still be there. Obviously I won’t be, we won’t be, but perhaps [the forest will be].”

So yes, it’s okay to grieve the loss of a solitary sycamore on the other side of the world. And it’s okay to talk about this kind of grief.

Doug Hendrie

Deputy Environment + Energy Editor

It wasn’t just a tree: why it feels so bad to lose the iconic Sycamore Gap tree and others like it

Rebecca Banham, University of Tasmania

One night, someone cut down a tree. It wasn’t just any tree. The loss of the Sycamore Gap tree sent a nation into grief. But why?

Weekend long reads

Jon Fosse wins the 2023 Nobel Prize in Literature for giving ‘voice to the unsayable’

Alexander Howard, University of Sydney

For Jon Fosse, the fourth Norwegian to win the 2023 Nobel Prize in Literature, writing has been a way of surviving.

Patrick White was the first Australian writer to win the Nobel Prize in Literature – 50 years later, is he still being read?

Reuben Mackey, Monash University

The aura of a major literary prize will inevitably fade. What we are left with is the work itself.

Friday essay: Lessons in Chemistry – the real Prince Charming in this ‘bad romance’ is a good dog

Briohny Doyle, University of Sydney

Briohny Doyle picked up Lessons in Chemistry not for its sassy-romance cover – which this subversive international bestseller does not deliver – but because she heard it featured a ‘good dog’.

Closer relations between Australia and India have the potential to benefit both nations

Amitabh Mattoo, The University of Melbourne

Today there are few countries in the Indo-Pacific which share so much in common, in both values and interests, than India and Australia. Andrew Charlton’s new book examines the possibilities.

The rise and ‘whimper-not-a-bang’ fall of Australia’s trailblazing rock press

David Nichols, The University of Melbourne

David Nichols was a music journalist for more than a decade, starting in 1980. Samuel J. Fell’s new history of Australian rock writing takes him down memory lane.

Is marriage modern? Anna Kate Blair’s novel poses the question, but doesn’t answer it

Edwina Preston, The University of Melbourne

The Modern, a debut novel centred on an Australian researcher at New York’s MoMA, muses on modern art and relationships – riffing off MoMA artists like Grace Hartigan and Nan Goldin.

Utopia gone wrong: identity and history intersect in Jenny Erpenbeck’s haunting new novel

Isabelle Hesse, University of Sydney

In Kairos, a relationship between a young woman and an older married man captures the difficulties and ambivalences of German reunification.

Our new climate series, Getting to Zero

Introducing The Conversation’s new climate series, Getting to Zero

James Button, The Conversation

Getting to Zero, a new series in The Conversation starting today, examines how – and whether – Australia can meet its net zero emissions target by 2050.

The road is long and time is short, but Australia’s pace towards net zero is quickening

Anna Skarbek, Climateworks Centre

The widespread pessimism about our ability to solve climate change is misplaced. Australia is putting in place the fundamentals of a net zero future. Now we need to go faster.

Too hard basket: why climate change is defeating our political system

Judith Brett, La Trobe University

The rising climate crisis presents an existential threat to humanity yet our government and political system are on a go-slow response. Is this issue too hard for humans to solve?

Made in America: how Biden’s climate package is fuelling the global drive to net zero

Alan Finkel, The University of Queensland

The Biden Administration’s signature climate legislation is unleashing a wave of clean energy investment, along with some opportunities and risks for countries like Australia.

Our most-read article this week

Replacing gas heating with reverse-cycle aircon leaves some people feeling cold. Why? And what’s the solution?

Alan Pears, RMIT University; Nicola Willand, RMIT University; Sara Vahaji, RMIT University; Trivess Moore, RMIT University

People who switch from gas to reverse-cycle air conditioning to heat their homes still want to feel comfortable. Some don’t. Home electrification programs must tackle the causes of the problem.

In case you missed this week's big stories

 

Featured jobs

View all
NIDA
Kensington NSW, Australia • Full Time
List your job
 
 
 
 
 

Featured Events, Courses & Podcasts

View all
Spain's egg donation boom

1 January 2023 - 7 October 2026 •

Promote your event or course
 

​Contact us here to list your job, or here to list your event, course or podcast.

For sponsorship opportunities, email us here