Earlier this year, I airily told a friend I’m not afraid of ageing, because (I claimed) I’m not especially attached to how I look. But almost immediately, I began to be surprised and dismayed by the face I see in the mirror. I may not expect beauty, but as a nearly-50-year-old, it’s already hard to let go of the image of myself I didn’t even realise I carry.

Carol Lefevre puts a name to that bewildering feeling – homesickness for the self – in her exquisite essay on the hidden grief of ageing. Women, she says, often begin to experience it around 50, when their bodies “send the implacable signal that things have changed”. And as she approached her own 70th birthday, she realised she was about to cross a border: soon she would “be old, no question”.

Lefevre describes the nostalgia of recognising our distance from an irrecoverable youth as coming with “a jolt of emotion that felt like a bereavement”. But as with homesickness, she says, how badly we suffer depends on how we manage our relationship with the past – and our own internalised ageism.

She draws on personal reflection, her interviews with people aged 70 and older, and research and literature that speak perfectly to the grief, nostalgia and cognitive dissonance of ageing. “How can I be old?” asks nine-year-old Harriet, in a Penelope Lively story, when her mother says she’ll be her grandmother’s age one day. “I’m me.”

Lefevre says every one of her interviewees “"admits to feeling a vivid sense of the past, and the continuing presence of a younger self”. Jo, aged 84, points to a photograph of himself as a joyful, exuberant three-year-old as representing his essence.

Part of the grief of late-stage ageing, Carol reflects, is the “last man standing” loneliness of having lost everyone who knew you when you were young. But, she reminds us, it’s a privilege to become very old, too: “our bodies are capable of more severe betrayals than mere flabby armpits”.

Australia’s National Ageing Institute is addressing ageism with a language guide that asks us to avoid terms like “old person”. But, Lefevre argues, wouldn’t it be better to destigmatise the word “old” rather than avoid it?

“Old people need to start claiming their years with pride,” she concludes. While we can’t return to our younger selves, old age can be a kind of homecoming.

Jo Case

Deputy Books + Ideas Editor

Friday essay: homesick for ourselves – the hidden grief of ageing

Carol Lefevre, University of Adelaide

As we age, it can be hard to fathom the gap between our younger selves and the bodies we inhabit. Carol Lefevre explores this strange form of homesickness.

Weekend long reads

Naomi Klein (left), Naomi Wolf (right). Background protest Mick Tsikas/AP. Andre Dalmau/EPA, fleshmanpix/Flickr

In Doppelganger, Naomi Klein says the world is broken: conspiracy theorists ‘get the facts wrong but often get the feelings right’

Nick Haslam, The University of Melbourne

Naomi Klein uses her frequent confusion with ‘doppelganger’ Naomi Wolf to spark an exploration of doubles, mirror-worlds, and the gulf between left and right.

Leigh Sales (Bianca De Marchi/AAP), Samantha Maiden and Trent Dalton.

‘I just find it very hard to talk about it without getting emotional’: top journalists reveal their trade secrets to Leigh Sales

Kathryn Shine, Curtin University

Leigh Sales’ new book shares the insights of more than 30 prominent and experienced Australian journalists, including Laurie Oakes, Samantha Maiden and Trent Dalton, about their craft.

Polites traces Honour’s journey from her village scented with pine trees to suburban Australia. gkordus/Shutterstock

Peter Polites maps war, migration, familial love and gay identity from mid-century Greece to western Sydney

Anthony Macris, University of Technology Sydney

God Forgets About the Poor is one part family saga, one part autofiction, one part Proustian journey through memory.

Annie Spratt/unsplash

A memoir of sleeplessness posits making peace with our ruptured nights – but risks becoming an exhausting read

Liz Evans, University of Tasmania

The hunt for sleep has become a global industry, with apps, drugs, self-help remedies. In a new book, author Marie Darrieussecq contemplates the curse of insomnia.

Gin/Pexels

Can self-help books help with depression? I spoke to readers to find out

Amber Gwynne, The University of Queensland

Readers with depression initially wanted the ‘instant gratification of being fixed’ from self-help books. That didn’t happen, but they did benefit from the right books at the right times.

Our most-read article this week

The body mass index can’t tell us if we’re healthy. Here’s what we should use instead

Rachael Jefferson-Buchanan, Charles Sturt University

The BMI does not distinguish between excess body fat, bone mass or musculature. It also does not interpret the distribution of fat, which is a predictor of health.

In case you missed this week's big stories

How Qantas might have done all Australians a favour by making refunds so hard to get

Peter Martin, Crawford School of Public Policy, Australian National University

Price discrimination is charging customers who don’t mind paying more than those who do – and businesses do it all the time. But Qantas seems to have taken it to a new level.

Grattan on Friday: Langton and Price fight with passion and gloves off for beliefs

Michelle Grattan, University of Canberra

Marcia Langton is a woman who says what she thinks, and then some. Like Langton, Price gives no quarter.

The Greens were right to pass Australia’s Housing Future Fund bill – the case for further delay was weak

Brendan Coates, Grattan Institute

In agreeing to pass the Housing Australia Future Fund bill the Greens have got a lot of what they wanted. Their idea of funding building and Labor’s idea of subsidising rent aren’t that far apart.

NZ election 2023: with a month to go, polls point to a right-wing coalition government

Adrian Beaumont, The University of Melbourne

New Zealand’s proportional electoral system makes coalition governments all but inevitable. Ahead of the October 14 election, the jockeying for power is all on the right.

Devastatingly low Antarctic sea ice may be the ‘new abnormal’, study warns

Edward Doddridge, University of Tasmania; Ariaan Purich, Monash University

Sea ice around Antarctica has always followed a predictable seasonal cycle. Now, we’ve experienced a sudden dramatic loss, and the changes are here to stay.

Is it really safe to feed your cat a vegan diet?

Alexandra Whittaker, University of Adelaide

A new study has reportedly found benefits to feeding cats a vegan diet. We got an expert to look at whether the evidence stacks up.

What Manchester Museum’s return of 174 Indigenous artefacts tells us about the future of museums

Mike Jones, University of Tasmania

A focus on relationships is relatively new. But if museums are to remain relevant, trusted institutions they need to move beyond traditional models of authority.

Astronomers have discovered a rare ‘polar ring galaxy’ wrapped in a huge ribbon of hydrogen

Baerbel Koribalski, CSIRO

New ASKAP images reveal a giant hydrogen ring around the spiral galaxy NGC 4632.

Are we about to see a rare green comet light up the sky? An expert on what to expect from Nishimura

Jonti Horner, University of Southern Queensland

There’s a chance Nishimura might brighten unexpectedly – but it’s a slim one.

Apple wants to know if you’re happy or sad as part of its latest software update. Who will this benefit?

Peter Koval, The University of Melbourne; Benjamin Tag, Monash University; Greg Wadley, The University of Melbourne; Xanthe Lowe-Brown, The University of Melbourne

The iPhone already has an accelerometer, gyroscope, light meter, microphone, camera and GPS. Why does Apple now want you to tell it how you’re feeling?

 

Featured jobs

View all
NIDA
Kensington NSW, Australia • Full Time
Auckland University of Technology
Auckland, New Zealand • Full Time
Auckland University of Technology
Auckland, New Zealand • Full Time
List your job
 
 
 
 
 

Featured Events, Courses & Podcasts

View all
Rose Scott Women Writers’ Festival

15 - 17 September 2023 • Sydney

Deputies Leadership Program

18 September - 14 November 2023 • New Zealand

Promote your event or course
 

​Contact us here to list your job, or here to list your event, course or podcast.

For sponsorship opportunities, email us here